With the recent controversery surrounding who should have screening mammograms for the early detection of breast cancer, our own Breast Imaging Specialist Dr. Adrienne Hansen wrote the following position paper for the Wenatchee Valley Medical Center:
NEW MAMMOGRAPHY GUIDELINES
The Wenatchee Valley Medical Center does not accept the new mammography screening guidelines suggested by the United States Preventive Task Force Service. We continue to follow guidelines as put forth by the Society of Breast Imaging, the American Cancer Society and other respected professional organizations.
Provided a woman is not at increased risk for developing breast cancer, we recommend:
Yearly screening mammography starting at age 40 with no upper age limit.
Yearly clinical breast examination
Optional monthly breast self-examination.
Wenatchee Valley Medical Center
Position Statement on Breast Cancer Screening
In November 2009, The Annals of Internal Medicine published the US Preventive Services Task Force’s (USPSTF) updated recommendations for radical changes in the clinical guidelines for breast cancer screening [1].
In summary, these guidelines state that:
• Most women in their 40s should not routinely get mammograms
• Women aged 50-74 should get mammograms every two years
• Data is insufficient for recommending screening mammography once women reach age 75
• Women should not be taught Breast self-examination
• Evidence is insufficient to support health care providers performing Clinical Breast Exam
The Wenatchee Valley Medical Center does not accept these new recommendations. The federally funded and staffed Task Force includes representatives from major health insurers, but does not include a single radiologist, oncologist, breast surgeon, or any other clinician with demonstrated expertise in breast cancer diagnosis or treatment. We continue to follow guidelines as put forth by the Society of Breast Imaging, the American Cancer Society and other respected professional organizations.
Provided a woman is not at increased risk for developing breast cancer, we recommend:
Yearly screening mammography starting at age 40 with no upper age limit.
Yearly clinical breast examination
Optional monthly breast self-examination.
Over forty years of research has supported an unequivocal reduction in the risk of death for women undergoing screening mammography. In the United States, the mortality rate from breast cancer remained static for 50 years preceding the onset of national screening mammography in the mid 1980s. With the onset of rigorous screening mammography in 1990, the death rate has decreased by 30%, certainly a noteworthy achievement.
The USPSTF report underestimates this reduction to be 15% in women ages 39-49, 14% in women ages 50-59 and 32% in women ages 60-69, and uses these figures in their calculations of how many women need to be screened to save one life [2]. These are low estimates of benefit, and this figure ignores recent direct studies from the Netherlands and Sweden. Across all age groups, at 20 years of follow-up, women who participated in screening had a 44% decrease in risk of death from breast cancer (RR .56; 95% CI 0.49-0.64) compared to those who were not screened [3]. In British Columbia, there was a 40% decrease in deaths among women screened annually between ages 40 and 79 between 1998 and 2003, and a 39% reduction among women aged 40-49 at first screen [4].
Breast cancer is less common in women aged 40-49, which is why more women in this age group need to be screened to save the same number of lives when compared to older women. However, the number needed to screen produced by the USPSTF is significantly elevated due to the underestimation of the decrease in mortality rate discussed above and the use of a number needed to invite to screen instead of a number actually screened. The USPSTF used a 15% decrease in breast cancer deaths among women in their 40s invited to screen, and estimated that 1904 women in their 40s would need to be invited to screen to prevent one death from breast cancer. Using the USPSTF’s flawed algorithm and a modest 30% decrease in death, the number needed to screen drops to 952. As breast cancers in younger women often are faster growing, women in their 40s should be screened annually. The average size of a breast cancer diagnosed today is significantly smaller than cancers diagnosed 20 years ago.
While it is true that mammography is less well studied in women over the age of 75, breast cancer is more common in this age group. Women at age 75 vary greatly in their overall health and life expectancy. We believe that it should be an individual decision between a health care provider and a woman as to whether or not screening is appropriate, so that a healthy 75 year old woman may still potentially reap the benefits of screening.
High quality mammography, with radiologists who are considered high volume readers, helps to cut back on the additional testing (“harms”) of mammography. Mammography should not be limited to high risk women, since approximately 75% of breast cancers are diagnosed in those with no risk factor other than their age and being female.
We do agree that monthly, regimented breast self-examination (BSE) is not appropriate for all women and may bring anxiety to some. For women who are comfortable performing BSE, we do not discourage it. All women should be encouraged to report clinical concerns to their health care provider.
Clinical breast examination (CBE; performed by a health care provider) is complementary to mammography since a small percentage of breast cancers are felt but are mammographically occult. We believe that clinicians should continue to be trained and should continue to perform CBE as part of a routine physical examination.
A. Adrienne Hansen, M.D.
Breast imager, Department of Radiology
1. Preventive Services Task Force. Screening for breast cancer: U.S. Preventive Services Task Force recommendation statement. Ann Intern Med 2009;151:716-726.
2. Nelson HD, Tyne K, Naik A, Bougatsos C, Chan BK, Humphrey L. Screening for breast cancer: an update for the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force. Ann Intern Med 2009;151:727-737.
3. Tabar L, Yen MF, Vitak B, Chen HH, Smith RA, Duffy SW. Mammography service screening and mortality in breast cancer patients: 20-year follow-up before and after introduction of screening. Lancet. 2003;361(9367):1405–1410.
4. Coldman A, Phillips M, Warren L, Kan L. Breast cancer mortality after screening in British Columbia women. Int J Cancer 2007;120:1076–1080.
5. Berg WA, Hendrick RE, Kopans DB, Smith RA. Frequently asked questions about mammography and the USPSTF recommendations: a guide for practitioners. www.sbi-online.org.
Recent Comments